HPL brings back library card checks at Central Library due to “increase in incidents”
The Hamilton Public Library (HPL) has brought back a temporary requirement for visitors to show a library card at Central Library in Downtown Hamilton. The library says incidents at the branch are rising again.
The Check-In Protocol was reinstated on Oct. 13 and is scheduled to remain in place through Apr. 5, 2027.
“We are seeing an increase in incidents at Central Library and visible, daily drug use on York Boulevard,” said HPL Communications Manager Shelley McKay in a statement.
“With incidents historically increasing during fall and winter, HPL is reinstating the protocol to help prevent further escalation, keep Central Library open and maintain access to library services.”
The measure follows a two-month Library Card Access Pilot that ran from Mar. 16 to May 17, 2026. The HPL Board approved the pilot in a 7-2 vote on Mar. 11. Councillor Cameron Kroetsch (Ward 2 – Downtown Hamilton) and citizen board member Kojo Damptey voted against it.
The pilot was introduced, McKay said, “after illegal drug use, drug distribution activity and emergency responses escalated at Central Library in late 2025 and early 2026, to the point that closing the facility was being considered.”
“The pilot helped keep Central Library open and maintain services,” she said.
McKay said that compared with the period just before the pilot, “naloxone administrations decreased by more than 90 per cent, the rate of 9-1-1 calls fell by approximately 67 per cent, and the rate of suspected illegal drug use fell by more than half.”
"*" indicates required fields
She added that “new memberships also increased by approximately 35 per cent compared with the same period in 2025.”
After the pilot ended, HPL said the card requirement would only be used again as “an interim operational tool” when other interventions proved insufficient.
McKay said existing supports are no longer enough.
“HPL has long provided supports for people facing challenges alongside safety measures,” she said. “Those efforts have become insufficient to manage the safety and service challenges we are experiencing.”
The spring pilot went to a board vote. This time, the decision was made by staff.
“The decision was an operational one made by library leadership, and the Library Board was informed,” McKay said. “It drew on current conditions, historical incident patterns, the spring pilot evaluation and feedback from Members, Staff and community partners.”
The pilot drew opposition from the Hamilton Public Library Workers Union (CUPE 932), which called it “carding.” Advocates also argued it could exclude vulnerable residents.
McKay said the library’s evaluation “documented concerns about access and inclusion alongside these safety improvements, and both informed the updated protocol.”
“We learned from the pilot and have updated the approach to support access,” she said.
Under the reinstated protocol, a library card is not needed to enter or exit the building through York Boulevard or Jackson Square. The check-in applies to adults 18 and older who go beyond the first-floor corridor. Children and teens under 18 are exempt.
Each member may bring up to two guests, “who do not need their own card or identification,” according to McKay.
First-floor programs, social worker and community partner supports, and holds pickup are still available without a card.
Visitors without a card can ask staff for help using a washroom, and a security staff member will go with them.
Information Desk staff can help visitors get a library card. McKay said, “Government-issued identification is not required to get a card, and this has been the case for more than a decade.”
The protocol applies only at Central Library. A notice about it is posted on HPL’s website.
HPL says it will monitor conditions and review the protocol’s effects before Apr. 5. It will announce any changes to the process or schedule.
“We continue to work with community partners and advocate for meaningful changes that address the underlying issues, while keeping Library spaces safe and welcoming,” McKay said.