The OSAP flap
The OSAP saga is merely one example of how our scarce tax dollars are wasted and abused.
The Ontario Student Assistance Program (OSAP) has been much in the news of late, and not for good reasons. The Ford government is in the process of making significant changes to OSAP for private postsecondary institutions following preliminary findings of an audit of the program by the KPMG accounting firm. KPMG found considerable fraud and misuse in the private institution sector. As a result, the Ontario government paused OSAP payments and funding on Oct. 6, 2026. The pause did not apply to public colleges and universities. The government has said the pause will apply until 2027 but was not more specific about the timing as officials said a new approval and oversight process needed to be put in place before the grants and loans started to flow again. The pause will affect applications for 2025-26 and 2026-27.
Although a final report has not yet been published, preliminary results from the KPMG audit found such things as common ownership structures among various private institutions, links with immigration services firms, co-location of private career colleges and immigration services firms, poor validation of student eligibility and thousands of applications linked to a single IP address and coming from a single geographic location. Online-only programs were found to be especially problematic as students who spent very little time online were nevertheless given credit for passing courses. There was also evidence of final exams being completed in minutes and enrolled students who were unable to name the school or program in which they were enrolled.
In addition to pausing the OSAP program for private institutions, the Ontario government has also issued non-renewal notices to several campuses that will not be permitted to use the OSAP program until at least 2030. In future, the government has said all private colleges will have to meet stricter conditions to be eligible to participate in OSAP. The Ontario government has also notified the provincial Auditor-General and has referred the matter to the Ontario Provincial Police. The KPMG audit is ongoing, but the province does not plan to release the final report to the public, although they might share selected information if it does not interfere with police or other future investigations, or efforts to recoup funds obtained fraudulently.
Naturally the blowback from individuals who were planning or had already applied for OSAP funding was immense. Despite the fact that a post-secondary education should pay for itself through better job opportunities and higher compensation, students over the past couple of decades have become more and more dependent on government grants and loans. Acknowledging that students counting on OSAP monies may have problems financing their education, the government has said it will work with financial institutions to facilitate the availability of low-interest loans for affected individuals during this period of transition until the new rules are in place.
The Ontario government has been criticized for being too slow to react to the clear abuse of OSAP and for not monitoring the program closely enough. There is certainly a solid basis for this criticism, as between the 2023-24 and 2024-25 academic years, OSAP grants for private career colleges almost doubled to about $1 billion. Apparently, the Ministry of Colleges and Universities also received many tips and complaints regarding overly active recruitment by these colleges and fraudulent OSAP applications.
"*" indicates required fields
Although criticism of the Ford government and the provincial bureaucracy that didn’t seem to be very on the ball about all of the signals there was something very wrong with this program is justified, the federal government must also share the blame. The pressure on OSAP was largely due to the federal Liberal government’s ongoing chaotic immigration policies which permitted many individuals into Canada on student visas that were not really students at all. A number of these private career colleges saw the opportunity presented by a massive influx of fake students who were merely wanting to get into Canada by any means possible and pretended they were taking and completing post-secondary courses so they could dishonestly fulfill the conditions of having a student visa. So although the Ontario government is certainly on the hook for this expensive mess, the federal government must also shoulder a significant part of the blame.
There are many morals to this story. Poor government oversight of the hundreds of billions of our tax dollars we submit to them every year exists at every level of government and is an absolute outrage. The OSAP saga is merely one example of how our scarce tax dollars are wasted and abused. It’s likely that zero heads will roll over the mismanagement of OSAP and the many wasted tax dollars that were fraudulently obtained. Although the Ontario government claims it will go after reimbursement of improperly obtained funds, the likelihood of that happening is slim to none. We Canadians are far too tolerant of governments of all political stripes that abuse our trust and our hard-earned money. That must end if we are to see a well-functioning economy and society that realizes fairness for all citizens.