Hockey Night in Canada signs off – Part Two

Dave Redekop
· 6 min read

If part one of this series covered some stories and examined why Hockey Night in Canada (HNIC) became part of our national social fabric, part two will explore why the legacy will continue. The end of HNIC will not be the end of Saturday night hockey; it will not close the door on Canadians gathering around screens to watch their heroes spend their last ounce of strength trying to win the Stanley Cup. The role that HNIC played in our collective lives will ensure the tradition remains a vibrant part of Canadiana. Looking back at the program’s early years reveals a technology quickly adapting to a new way of transmitting a live event. CBC radio broadcasts emerged in 1936 from an initial deal that MacLaren Advertising Agency inked with the Toronto Maple Leafs and Conn Smythe, the team’s owner in 1931, coinciding with the opening of Maple Leaf Gardens. By 1934, Imperial Oil took over the broadcast, renamed it The Imperial Esso Hockey Broadcast, and a survey found that 74 per cent of the radio audience tuned in to Saturday night hockey, making it a wildly popular program and a very attractive property. When CBC took over, Foster Hewitt brought the broadcast with him and coined the term Hockey Night in Canada. Powerful 50,000-watt flagship stations in Toronto and Montreal let fans hear the games on the radio, even in U.S. cities with NHL teams such as Detroit, Boston, New York, and Chicago. This likely explains Hewitt’s trademark Saturday night welcome: “Hello, Canada, and hockey fans in the United States and Newfoundland.” The Saturday night radio broadcasts continued until 1965, when CBC shifted its focus to the booming growth in television. An effort to keep radio broadcasts alive moved them to Sunday evenings. This lasted for about 10 years and eventually led to the regional rights that each team now negotiates with local affiliates. 

SATELLITE HOT STOVE

The HNIC broadcasts on television, as noted in the previous article, have their own story. The 100% Hockey podcasts cited remain a rich source for understanding how HNIC developed what Rogers’ broadcasts will seek to continue. When John Shannon and Daren Millard spoke with various members of the HNIC crew, they added a new layer of learning to the panel discussions. One of the more fascinating exchanges occurred when the podcast invited the old Satellite Hot Stove team of John Davidson, Al Strachan, and Jim Hughson. The SHS attempted to bring hockey news from across the continent, presented by three different voices, into one conversation. Coach’s Corner with Don Cherry amassed huge ratings during the first-period intermission. How could HNIC replicate that magic during period two’s break? With Davidson, Hughson, and Strachan at the helm, second intermission ratings matched those of Cherry and MacLean in a short period. Beginning in 1995, when HNIC expanded to doubleheaders on Saturday nights, SHS used cutting-edge satellite technology to connect pundits and insiders stationed in different arenas and studios across North America simultaneously. Instead of just local coverage, fans got a true coast-to-coast debate panel. The intent was to liven up the recess with rumours, news, and speculation about events in different locales. Hughson was the voice of the Vancouver Canucks and spoke for Western Canada. Davidson, a John Madden-like character, according to Shannon, spoke for the United States, while Strachan, sitting beside Ron MacLean in the studio, spoke for Eastern Canada. They also represented different interests in the game. Hughson was a play-by-play announcer, Davidson had played in the NHL for several seasons, and Strachan was an old-time journalist. As Shannon recalled, “…his (Strachan’s) loyalty was not to the teams; it was not to the league. His loyalty was to have a cutting edge, tell the truth style…he was a pretty entertaining guy…”

THE RECOLLECTIONS

Davidson recalled the challenge of finding a studio to work from on Saturday night, especially if he was not already calling a Rangers game. This was before Zoom, home connections, or iPhones. The hook-ups had to be in studios, but Davidson always found a way into Canadians’ homes, thanks to the technical genius at HNIC Productions. He also recalled several stories related to the difficulty of finding a studio. In one instance, while covering a game in Detroit, he had to return to a Windsor studio to record the hit, then head back to Detroit for the game. This all happened before NEXUS existed, back when every driver was required to pass through the booths, hoping that their lane wouldn’t experience a long delay. He managed to get back, but not without a narrow escape. On another occasion, the team taped a spot at 3:00 p.m. for an evening broadcast. The entire time they were recording, a Zamboni machine circled the ice, blasting at full steam. Only later was it revealed that someone behind the scenes had ordered the cleaning to distract and annoy the crew as they recorded. A final story the retired goalie told took place in Quebec City. Trying to find a studio was hard enough, but no one spoke English, and Davidson, unfamiliar with French, found himself trying to ask for something with a language barrier between himself and his objective. It, too, like most situations, worked out, but not before there were some uncomfortable moments, tension, or uncertainty.  

Strachan, now retired from journalism, wrote a book in 2020 about some shenanigans on the show and the unsanitized debates that took place. As the show grew in popularity, the producers knew they had something special. When hockey management saw the guys around in various spots, they grew careful about their conversations, fearing those talks would be repeated during the second intermission on Saturday evening. Strachan felt the pressure to come up with different ideas and to have some news, even if it was a discussion about reducing the size of rinks from 100 feet to 86 feet, as they have in Finland. He gave Ron MacLean a lot of credit for orchestrating a great discussion based on the information, rumours, or possible news the three brought to the panel on any given evening. The strangest and possibly most humorous story he told involved Theo Fleury. As Strachan recollected: 

Theo Fleury had gone to the Rangers. And he’d had his drug problems, which are well-documented, and he was clean by then, and he was working very hard at staying that way. But there started to be rumours in the newspapers that he had been seen at a bar, and that he was drinking and doing drugs and everything. So I said, these stories are ridiculous. I said, he’s not doing that. I said, sure, he can go out at night. He can go to various things. He could go and entertain himself. He could go to a bar. He could go to a ballet or whatever he wants to do. But he’s not breaking the rules again. So I’m in the cab on the way home. John Rosasco calls. Said, “Slats (Glen Sather, manager of the NY Rangers) wants to talk to you.” Oh, great. So I have to call Slats. So I called Slats. He said, “What the hell are you doing? Saying that Fleury was out with ‌strippers at a strip bar?” I said, I didn’t say any such thing. I said, ” What I said was that he was at the ballet.” Only in the hockey world is the ballet a strip bar in Montreal.

Over six episodes, the stories about HNIC rolled off the tongues of the iconic broadcasters who ruled the airwaves for decades. 100% Hockey (episodes 95-100). Hockey will continue in Canada on Saturday nights. Fans will tune in via streaming platforms using apps. Others will watch the game on their devices, travelling from place to place, sitting in faraway places, even while working. The love affair with hockey will not end because HNIC no longer produces the games. Regardless, for three generations of hockey addicts, and for generations to come, those of us who love the game because of Saturday nights in front of those old TV screens, watching black and white images, memorizing names and lineups, will never forget the excitement we felt to know that for a few hours on a weekend night we could see our heroes in action, hear about news around the league, and possibly see an unpredictable result. Like Darryl Sittler’s 10-point night in February 1976 or Wayne Gretzky’s 50th goal in his 39th game of the 1981-82 season. May Rogers draw inspiration from the famous words in the Montreal Canadiens dressing room that remind players today, “To you from failing hands we throw the torch; be yours to hold it high.”

 

Dave Redekop
Columnist

Dave Redekop is a retired elementary resource teacher who now works part-time at the St. Catharines Courthouse as a Registrar. He has worked on political campaigns since high school and attended university in South Carolina for five years, where he earned a Master’s in American History with a specialization in Civil Rights. Dave loves reading biographies.

More from Dave Redekop →