Separatism is stronger in Alberta than Quebec

Lee Harding
· 3 min read

Quebec has been eclipsed by Alberta in the strength of its separatist sentiment. Now a higher percentage of Albertans want the question of leaving Canada put to a vote than Quebecers do. That finding should raise eyebrows and prompt attention from Ottawa, but will it?

The two million people who voted in Alberta’s official plebiscite presented a clear picture. For every Albertan who wanted the province to present a chance to leave Canada, three did not. A majority of Albertans in almost every provincial electoral district do not want a vote on independence.

Nevertheless, the stats also suggest that a higher percentage of Albertans do want such a vote compared to Quebecers. A Léger poll released Oct. 20 found that only 20 per cent of people wanted new PQ premier Paul St-Pierre Plamondon to hold a referendum on Quebec sovereignty while 67 per cent were opposed to the idea. (That leaves 13 per cent unsure or undecided).

This suggests Quebec’s ratio of those who want a referendum to those who don’t is 1:3.35. That’s a weaker ratio than the 1:3 we find in Alberta. That is a significant finding.

Curiously, the Leger poll found that 29 per cent of Quebeckers support Quebec sovereignty, even though only 20 per cent of Quebeckers wanted a referendum to be held in this term. Presumably, some people who like the concept nevertheless think there is no point in holding a vote, since nothing will change until there’s more support for their position.

If a similar phenomenon is going on in Alberta, support for independence there is probably higher than 25 per cent and probably more like 37. That’s still nowhere near majority territory, but it is certainly sizable.

Canadian federalism has been skewed in Quebec’s direction ever since the Parti Québécois made it so. The party was formed in 1968 with independence as its ultimate objective but didn’t gain power until 1976. On Dec. 20, 1979, the PQ government formally announced that a referendum on sovereignty would take place. This announcement was made just one week after the Joe Clark Progressive Conservative budget was voted down in the House of Commons, forcing an election.

In the campaign that followed, senior Liberal Party campaign strategist Keith Davey said, “Screw the West, we’ll take the rest.” The strategy worked. The Pierre Trudeau Liberals were elected back to power on Feb. 18, 1980, and took office March 3. On May 20, Quebecers had a referendum on Quebec sovereignty, but almost 60 per cent said no.

Ever since then, Quebec has been placated at the expense of the rest of Canada, especially the West. Trudeau introduced the National Energy Program, setting prices on fuel and even establishing a federal Crown corporation to sell it. He did not care about the uproar in Alberta, but famously said, “I came to Ottawa to save Quebec. Somebody else is going to have to save the West.”

Quebec has received equalization payments every year since the program began in 1957. Trudeau made sure that program was entrenched in Section 36(2) of the constitution he helped draw up. Quebec refused to sign the document, but it’s binding on them anyway. Subsequent efforts under the Brian Mulroney Progressive Conservatives failed to resolve the constitutional impasse. His government did, however, manage to award a 20-year jet maintenance contract to a Montreal company instead of a Winnipeg one, thanks in large part to political considerations.

The PQ government held another referendum in 1995 where just 50.58 per cent of Quebecers voted no. The scare prompted a flurry of Jean Chrétien Liberal federal advertising dollars to go to Quebec companies without proper procedure. Ad Scam helped topple his government, yet when the Stephen Harper Conservatives took power, they did so on a promise to increase equalization payments.

Quebec favouritism lasts to this day. Issues of special concern to that province, such as French titles appearing first on Netflix, and minimal tariffs on aluminum, were among the final factors that broke down a new U.S.-Canada trade deal.

While the Mark Carney Liberals may need Quebec support to maintain its majority, a more objective federal government would pay more attention to the disgruntled in Alberta than Quebec. Quebec has been treated unfairly well to bribe it to remain in the country. Alberta was left holding the financial bag not only for Quebec but for Canada and getting little in return.

If Trudeau was right, and “someone else” must save the West, we need that person now. It’s time for the equalization program to be revised and scaled down, net zero concerns to be put on the backburner, and for Ottawa to respect constitutionally-derived provincial authority instead of trying to put its nose into everything.