Where Hamilton’s leading mayoral candidates stand on property taxes, the rain tax, and more
Municipal election day in Hamilton is this Monday, October 26, with polls open from 10 a.m. to 8 p.m.
Leading mayoral candidates Rob Cooper, Andrea Horwath, and Keanin Loomis have all made their pitch to voters throughout the campaign.
Here is where they stand on major issues.
PROPERTY TAX INCREASES
ROB COOPER: Says he will “end tax increases exceeding inflation.” His website also says that he will ensure that residents “receive better value and better service from City Hall.” If elected, he says the city will produce monthly financial statements, complete audited financial statements on time, and publicly report on whether city services are meeting “clear performance standards.” He has committed to eliminating “wasteful spending” and will “reform procurement to focus on value, quality and life-cycle costs, and benchmark Hamilton against other municipalities.”
ANDREA HORWATH: Over the past four years, Horwath oversaw property tax increases of 5.85 per cent, 5.79 per cent, 5.6 per cent, and 3.87 per cent. She has defended those increases, saying they were necessary due to the city’s infrastructure deficit. Her campaign website says that she is now committed to “property tax increases below inflation.” She also says that she will develop “emergency deferral, reduction, and elimination options for city taxes and fees so a city bill is never the reason a struggling business closes its doors or a family falls behind.”
KEANIN LOOMIS: Keanin Loomis has not committed to a specific number for property tax increases. He told The Hamilton Spectator that promising a specific rate is a “campaign gimmick.” His website says that if he is elected city services will be “regularly required to show what they deliver, what it costs and whether there is a better way.” However, he says his platform is about “finding waste and getting better value — not cutting the services Hamilton relies on.” He says he will also review how City Hall is organized, including management and staffing.
STORMWATER FEE RAIN TAX
ROB COOPER: Cooper says he will “end the proposed rain tax,” which he also calls a “food tax” given that it will disproportionately impact businesses with impervious services, such as greenhouses.
ANDREA HORWATH: Horwath voted in favour of the new tax and has defended it publicly.
"*" indicates required fields
KEANIN LOOMIS: Loomis has not made a decision on the policy. He told The Hamilton Spectator that he will wait until next year to make his decision, when city staff provide a new report forward on the matter.
PUBLIC SAFETY
ROB COOPER: Cooper says he will restore a greater role for police engagement in schools and invest in community programs for young people. He says he will support Hamilton Police and supports “proactive enforcement and visible policing.” He says he will also sit on the Hamilton Police Service Board.
ANDREA HORWATH: Andrea Horwath notably resigned from the Hamilton Police Service Board in September 2025, citing a busy schedule. During the term, she supported Hamilton Police Service’s Core Patrol program and their new Jackson Square substation. Her platform says she will create “a Downtown Integrated Care and Response Team” that brings together municipal enforcement, outreach workers, and social service partners. She says she will also work to address “hate.”
KEANIN LOOMIS: Loomis’ platform says he will serve on the Hamilton Police Service Board for his full term. He says he will establish “measurable priorities” for police “to see whether our public-safety efforts are producing results.” He adds that Hamiltonians make “significant investment in policing” and that he will make “fiscal responsibility” one of the measurable priorities.
VACANT UNIT TAX
ROB COOPER: Cooper campaigned against the Vacant Unit Tax during his run for Ward 8 Councillor. During the mayoral campaign, he once again said that he will scrap the tax. He has called both the rain tax and vacant unit tax “unnecessary” and said that they “burden residents and slow development.”
ANDREA HORWATH: Horwath has declared a conflict of interest when voting on the Vacant Unit Tax in every vote since January 2024 since she has owned a vacant unit during that entire time. However, she has expressed support for the tax.
KEANIN LOOMIS: According to The Public Record Loomis told the Hamilton District Apartment Association that he would change the declaration process for the Vacant Unit Tax so that only those with vacant units have to declare their occupancy status. After that change is made, he said, “then we can see what the real costs are and what the real benefits are to the city.”