Do Canadians, and Carney, understand what’s at stake in the U.S. midterms?

Dave Redekop
· 7 min read

Trying to explain to people the difference between President Donald Trump’s behaviour and his policies resembles trying to describe a vaccination shot to a child. It may not be a perfect analogy, but the overlap occurs when the eventual benefit justifies the pain. The Maven of Mar-a-Lago could never be accused of explaining things artfully. Instead, he rambles, delves into matters of little relevance, and often attacks his opponents or detractors with personal and guttural insults. It adds little to the debate and provides ammunition for those who prefer to dismiss him as a narcissist bent on increasing his treasury at the expense of the nation’s wealth. Canadians have become used to viewing Trump through a very jaded lens. His huffing and puffing about a 51st state, calling our prime ministers governors, or the on-again, off-again trade and tariff talk have added nothing to his stature in America’s northern neighbour and have probably diminished most Canadians’ affections towards their American cousins. Regardless, does the present state of Canadian-American relations reflect where this relationship should stand as Americans prepare to elect a new Congress? Could the results of the election bring some positive benefits to Canada? Will the start of the 2028 presidential race mark the beginning of the end of Trump’s presidency and allow Canadians to reset their relationship with America? 

THE PRESENT STATE OF CANADA AND UNITED STATES RELATIONS

How bad are things between Canada and the United States? Probably as bad as they have been since at least the Diefenbaker era in the 1960s. Trump and Prime Minister Mark Carney both believe that a nation’s success depends on its economic growth rate. They may differ on many other matters, but on this issue, both men understand the need for job growth, development, and expanding markets. Negotiating a mutually beneficial agreement has eluded the men and their teams for some time now. 

The demand from Trump that Canada remove barriers and tariffs has met with resistance from Carney’s Liberals because certain industries, like dairy, are politically sacrosanct to the banker’s ideals. Carney has no patience for Trump’s interest in breaking the dairy board so he can get hormone-rich milk and dairy products on Canadian grocery shelves. Trump just wants a deal. He couldn’t care less about allergies, the effect of hormones on puberty, or whether a dairy board has created the highest standard of care in the world. What citizens hear or see about dairy board haggling can be applied to other matters as well. In Trump’s world, negotiations begin on economic principles. 

For Carney, the Trump conundrum has presented both pluses and minuses. Haggling with your number one trade partner was not on his dance card. But the temptation to use the Trump hysteria in Canada for political advantage exceeds his ability to resist. Rather than tamping down the hostility, Carney has opted to play up the threat of an American invasion, going so far as to have his minister of defence oversee scenarios in which Canada had to defend its borders against an aggressive American advance. It may be true, as Minister David McGuinty suggested, that all risk scenarios have to be accounted for, but releasing this to the Canadian press did little to calm the frayed nerves of those living on the border, especially those with their elbows raised and their fears on edge. Trump had no business making the threats he did about Canada’s sovereignty, but Carney should not be turning Canadians’ feelings about Trump into ones that define our fondness for our American friends. Few in the press called him on this and chose to indulge in the fearmongering. It may boost Carney’s poll numbers in the short term and give him greater leverage in his effort to become a global icon in Europe, but Canada needs to resolve these disputes with the United States, not nurture them. 

Relations between Canada and the United States have ebbed. Surely Trump deserves his share of the blame, but Carney has allowed political gain to outweigh the nation’s interest on this file. Simply electing a new president may begin the healing process, but if Carney continues his reckless effort to consolidate power in Canada while breeding hatred of Trump and the millions who support him, he could also engineer unforeseen problems for himself. 

COULD THE 2026 U.S. MIDTERM ELECTIONS BRING RELIEF?

Many Canadians prefer Democrats to Republicans in most elections, absent Trump. After six years of the Trump presidency, Canadians’ hopes rest on a Democratic sweep of the House and Senate. The logic of this argument rests on the Democrats restoring order to government business. This means that trade agreements will be rewritten and returned to their former status. The United States will again be a reliable partner, and the president will have to pay for his sins with investigations, impeachment hearings, and the possibility of conviction for his high crimes and misdemeanours. 

This writer would not be the first to dispel the notion in Canada that little will change regardless of who wins the midterms. Congressional leadership matters for the passage of legislation, but only massive majorities can override presidential vetoes, a scenario no one would anticipate at this juncture. If the Democrats seize the House, it will lead to political deadlock for two years, a lot of arguments, and any effort to investigate the president and eventually impeach him would be fraught with the lessons of having done so during his interregnum between terms one and two. Trump will continue to pursue his policies but will face greater headwinds. He will continue to dominate the news, post on Truth Social, and hold rallies. The 2028 nomination races will heat up, and he will play a pivotal role in determining who becomes the Republican nominee. 

As for the Democrats, notwithstanding the narratives that are now presented, they were pathologically protectionist regarding American industry long before the Trump era had even commenced. They fiercely opposed the free-trade initiatives of President Ronald Reagan and maintained widespread support from displaced union workers for decades. Now, they want to reclaim this share of the electoral pie which Trump siphoned off for the Republicans. 

Canadians expecting Democrats to return trade deals to their former status will be disappointed. The talk will be more polite, but the socialists who threaten to take over the old Democratic Party of liberals and corporatists will not countenance Canadian jobs over American workers. Cheering for Democrats to win because it means Trump will have lost may bring some satisfaction, but it will be short-term and lack any substantial advancement of Canadian interests. There will be no relief from Trump’s efforts to bring industry back to the United States, including auto plants. Democrats will be cheering and ready to lend a hand. Canadians who believe dominant media personalities championing Trump’s defeat in Canada are falling for fool’s gold. Protectionist policies are ascendant on the right and left in America. Either party will be America First, even if the rhetoric sounds warmer and fuzzier coming from the Democrats. 

THE 2028 RACE AND TRUMP’S FADE?  

Mark Twain’s famous line about his demise being overreported comes to mind. Trump most resembles a cat. His many lives allow him to escape capture, incarceration, or extermination. Trump will find a way to stay relevant throughout the 2028 process because, for all his foibles, he is a media genius. He knows how to stay in the news; he owns the press like no president ever has. They take his bait, fall for his traps, and constantly beclown themselves by predicting his end. 

Whoever wants to lead the Republicans in 2028 will have to receive the blessing of Trump and the MAGA crowd. If the Democrats win the midterms, as expected, who knows what trouble they will stir up among the electorate? Could this bolster Trump’s popularity? Democrats are not popular in America, and a misreading of the unhappiness with Trump in 2026 could cause them to nominate a socialist who has little appeal in middle America, similar to former vice president Kamala Harris in 2024. 

Writing off Donald Trump is like writing off mosquitoes in winter. They will be back and sometimes more ferocious than ever. It would be hasty and unwise to assume that Trump could not rebound. If the war in Iran is concluded, with nuclear weapons accounted for and oil prices in decline, he could enjoy renewed support. If economic growth accelerates, employment improves, and trade deals are resolved, Trump could still be relevant until his term ends in early 2029. 

The prime minister has set out to play “Chicken,” counting on Trump’s unpopularity in Canada to help him stay on top. Carney may win like a Las Vegas gambler, but it should be clear that no one knows how this story will end. Canada has decided to throw its lot in with a banker intent on gambling in a high-stakes game of poker. Who holds the best cards? The most dominant economic and military power in history, or its plucky northern neighbour, rich in resources, but in a race to reduce generational dependence on its larger next-door defender? Carney better hope that his brimming confidence in his ability to out-duel America and its president pays off. Otherwise, as in the United States, a new leader will take office in Canada in 2029.

 

Dave Redekop
Columnist

Dave Redekop is a retired elementary resource teacher who now works part-time at the St. Catharines Courthouse as a Registrar. He has worked on political campaigns since high school and attended university in South Carolina for five years, where he earned a Master’s in American History with a specialization in Civil Rights. Dave loves reading biographies.

More from Dave Redekop →